Currently Reading...

Just finished...

Review: If I Were You (Margolis)

Mrs. ReaderPants reviews If I Were You by Leslie Margolis...A cute book for tween girls! I just bought this from our school book fair, and I know it will be popular in the library.

AUTHOR: Leslie Margolis
SERIES: none
PUBLISHER: Farrar, Straus and Giroux
ISBN: 9780374300685
PAGES: 224
SOURCE: my library
GENRE: magical realism
SETTING: Malibu, California; summertime

SUMMARY: Twelve-year old besties Melody and Katie haven’t been getting along lately. Technically, they are still best friends, but each one is secretly annoyed by and jealous of the other’s life. On the last day of summer, both girls make a wish that they could start the summer all over again, this time as the other friend.

WHAT I LIKED: Comparisons to Freaky Friday are inevitable here, except this time, it’s two friends switching places. Freaky Friday is an older movie and book, so if your students don’t know it, you could always show them the movie trailer or a clip from the movie.

This book is incredibly easy to booktalk with sixth and seventh grade girls. The cover is cute, and it looks like a fun summer read. We are selling this book in our school’s book fair this week, and it’s sold well, especially with my sixth grade girls.

The theme of being jealous of a friend’s life rings true. Katie and Melody each think the other’s life is just perfect, and this at the heart of their recent arguments and irritation with one another. Many 11- and 12-year old girls will identify.

I liked the girls’ voices and felt they were well-drawn as characters.

WHAT I DIDN’T LIKE: The biggest thing that put me off is how these 12-year old girls are portrayed as though they are 15 or 16. Both girls go anywhere they want to in town without adult supervision. Katie goes around town wearing Melody’s mother’s skimpy dresses and makeup. Melody kisses a boy (her secret boyfriend) in a hot tub. Maybe I’m a big prude here, but I think that’s way too mature behavior for 12-year old girls.

THEMES: friendship, jealousy, the-grass-is-not-greener

THE BOTTOM LINE: It’s cute for middle school girls, but be forewarned that the 12-year old characters exhibit some mature behaviors for their age.

STATUS IN MY LIBRARY: We just bought a copy from our school book fair. I expect it to circulate well with middle school girls.



  • Overall: 3/5
  • Creativity: 3/5
  • Characters: 4/5
  • Engrossing: 3/5
  • Writing: 3/5
  • Appeal to teens: 5/5
  • Appropriate length to tell the story: 5/5


  • Language: none
  • Sexuality: medium; hot tub kissing, a much older man hits on 12-year old girl
  • Violence: none
  • Drugs/Alcohol: none

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

I accept the Privacy Policy

    Your Cart
    Your cart is emptyReturn to Shop