I liked Sun and Moon and Ice and Snow okay, but I’m not jumping out of my chair over it. Middle school students who like fairytale retellings will appreciate that this is a mix of Beauty and the Beast and Snow White and Rose Red.
AUTHOR: Jessica Day George
PUBLICATION DATE: January 1, 2008
SOURCE: my library
GENRE: fairy tale retelling, animal fantasy
SETTING: small town in a very cold country, has the medieval time period of most fairy tales
GIVE IT TO: MS
SUMMARY OF SUN AND MOON AND ICE AND SNOW
A young girl with the ability to communicate with animals is asked to help a large white bear in an ice palace. The ice palace and all its inhabitants, including the bear, are under a troll princess’s curse.
REVIEW OF SUN AND MOON AND ICE AND SNOW
This book is based on a Norwegian fairy tale similar to “Beauty and the Beast” and to a lesser extent, “Snow White and Rose Red.”
The female protagonist is the youngest of 12 children. Because she was unfortunate enough to be born last and female, her mother never bothers to give her a name. I never understood why no one else in the family (particularly her father or oldest brother) ever gave her a name, especially since the nameless were at risk of kidnapping by trolls.
Despite the girl’s lack of a formal name, the family calls her the “pika,” or little girl. Her oldest brother calls her “lass.”
When she is about nine years old, the pika saves a white reindeer from hunters and is blessed with the ability to talk to animals. This serves her well until one night, an ice bear wants the pika to come live with him for a year and a day.
I thought the first half, where the pika’s character and her family dynamics are being set-up, was much more interesting than the second half. This is a very large, very poor family, and the mother especially is someone readers will love to hate. She’s not evil, but she is pretty horrible to the pika.
The mystery surrounding the oldest brother Hans Peter was also interesting and well-written. I loved the winter wonderland setting throughout; George’s descriptions of the winter landscape made me feel like I was right there.
While I enjoyed the first half, I lost interest in the second half, where the pika lives in the ice castle. There isn’t much going on in the castle. The pika eats, talks with the bear, tries to read the troll carvings, and asks too many questions. But from day to day, not much happens beyond the mystery of what’s going on with the troll curse.
I also never felt connected to the bear and felt the romance lacked chemistry.
THEMES: belonging, loneliness, family, animal rights
THE BOTTOM LINE: It’s okay. The first half is better than the second half.
STATUS IN MY LIBRARY: We have it. I booktalked it last week with a class, and one girl put it on-hold for when I finished.
- Overall: 3/5
- Creativity: 4/5
- Characters: 3/5
- Engrossing: 2/5
- Writing: 4/5
- Appeal to teens: 3/5
- Appropriate length to tell the story: 3/5
- Language: none
- Sexuality: mild; mild fairy tale kissing; a strange man sleeps in the pika’s bed each night, but they just sleep
- Violence: mild; hunting animals, evil magic
- Drugs/Alcohol: none