REVIEW: I've wanted to read this book for quite awhile now! The author, AJ Betts, came to our school last March and went down like a storm. She was interesting, funny, and well-prepared for the presentation, and I highly recommend her for a visit if your school can get her. During the presentation, she completely sold me and the teens in the audience on Zac & Mia. We got 5 copies of it for the library, and they have since stayed consistently checked out. Some have even read it twice.
What I loved most about this book is that, while comparisons to The Fault in Our Stars are inevitable, I thought Zac & Mia was so much better. I've made no secret of how underwhelmed I was with TFIOS (easily my most controversial review). I've worked with teens for 13 years, and I'm sorry, but Hazel and Augustus do not sound like teenagers--they sound just like John Green. Zac and Mia actually sound like teenagers; I can tell AJ Betts works with teens on a daily basis.
I also really liked how slowly Zac and Mia's relationship develops. Mia is a very angry young lady, and I personally was ready to choke her a couple of times. But she's still likeable because her pain is so real. Mia's character growth is complex and believable. Love, love, love!
I did not cry or even come close to that in predictable TFIOS, but I did have a moment of tears toward the end. That ending was perfect for this book.
There is some content that is probably not appropriate for middle school, but I did not know that and as I mentioned, this book has made the rounds at my school. I've had no parent complaints so far. For me, mature content isn't something I worry much about, but I know many middle school librarians do try to keep it to a minimum. If you are concerned about mature content for middle school, this book definitely has it.
If I were still in high school and looking for a YA book to examine themes and symbols, Zac & Mia is full of good ones. The representation of mothers (Zac's mom, Mia's mom, Zac's pregnant sister, the farm animals, the fox trying to feed her babies), the emphasis on life and death on the farm, all the things the fox symbolizes (death, life, mothers, survival, nature). Lots of discussion material for book clubs and classrooms.
THEMES: friendship, cancer, mother-child relationships
THE BOTTOM LINE: Don't miss it. It's relatively short, meaningful, and beautifully-written. It's been a whopping hit at my school, thanks to the author visit and word of mouth. We even had some teachers raving about it.
STATUS IN MY LIBRARY: It's popular. We have 5 copies, and they stay checked out.
- Overall: 5/5
- Creativity: 5/5
- Characters: 5/5--characters are especially well-drawn
- Engrossing: 5/5
- Writing: 5/5
- Appeal to teens: 5/5
- Appropriate length to tell the story: 5/5
- Language: high--multiple F-bombs, sh**
- Sexuality: medium-high--Mia was previously sexually-active and does not hold back talking about that. Between Mia and Zac, there is nothing more than a kiss and lots of cute flirting.
- Violence: none
- Drugs/Alcohol: mild; cancer medications, Mia mentions being drunk in past
- Other: Mia contemplates suicide a couple of times
MORE TEENS IN CRISIS: