Monday, June 4, 2012

Review: Shadow and Bone (Bardugo)

AUTHOR: Leigh Bardugo
SERIES: The Grisha Trilogy, book 1
PUBLISHER: Henry Holt & Co.
ISBN: 9780805094596
PAGES: 368
SOURCE: Publisher's ARC
GENRE: dark fantasy
SUMMARY: Alina Starkov isn't remarkable. She grew up in an old estate as one of many orphans adopted and mainly unnoticed by a wealthy Duke. As a young child, Alina met Mal, another orphan who became her only friend and, as they grow older, her secret crush. But Alina's feelings for Mal are not her only secret. To avoid being forced to leave Mal's side, Alina has for years "pushed down" a powerful magic inside her, knowing it would cause her to be taken away. But when Alina must use her power to save Mal's life, she is separated from Mal and taken to the royal court to train as a Grisha, a group of people whose supernatural abilities assist the king.

REVIEW: What's not to love? Shadow and Bone has everything I crave in a YA fantasy: magic, romance, extravagance, good versus evil, darkness and light, supernatural powers, incredibly unique world-building.

Diverse characters with varying motives will keep readers guessing about just who Alina can trust. Even though this is a good-versus-evil fantasy, Shadow and Bone never resorts to stock characters with either altruistic or nefarious motives. The "evil" characters seem to truly believe they are doing the right thing, complicating Alina's sense of right and wrong and causing her to constantly question herself. I love love love that no character, including the protagonists, is perfectly good or evil; as in real life, every character houses some good and some evil inside. Bardugo leaves her characters to make their own decisions about what to do, what to believe, who to trust.

Even though the "I-secretly-love-my-best-friend" storyline has been played over and over, I really believed in both protagonists' friendship and romance. Their tender moments didn't make my toes curl as do some other books' romances, but I rooted for them anyway. Some very sweet stuff there.

And now for the world-building--I saved the best for last! As I was reading, I kept thinking of the unique world-building in Roth's Divergent and Young's Blood Red Road. As with those two, I can think of no book that features a world like this one. The story takes place in war-torn Ravka, mainly within the extravagant royal court where the Grisha hone their supernatural abilities in order to serve the king. The Shadow Fold reminds me of "The Nothing" in The Never-Ending Story, a dark, barren area dividing Ravka in half. The Shadow Fold is incredibly dangerous and plagued with winged monsters called Volkra who feed on any who attempt to cross the sandy bleakness of The Unsea. Bardugo details every scene beautifully; I could easily picture the characters, the volkra, The Unsea, the snow, the clothing, the movement of magic. Yet despite the abundance of vivid detail, Bardugo's descriptions never weigh-down the story or stop the action. Like The Darkling's magic, the details simply "curl" and "unfurl" themselves into the action, allowing the reader to savor every second. Just WOW.

THE BOTTOM LINE: I have zero doubt that Shadow and Bone will appear on several "Best of 2012" lists by the end of this year. Beautifully written with complex characters and unique world-building, Shadow and Bone is a must-read for anyone who loves a fast-paced fantasy romance.

STATUS IN MY LIBRARY: On order. While it is well-paced, I don't think Shadow and Bone is for every reader. Give this one to more advanced readers who can be patient with a slow, suspenseful build-up where things are presented but not explained right away. I would not recommend Shadow and Bone to struggling or reluctant readers.

READALIKES: Divergent (Roth); Blood Red Road (Young)

  • Overall: 5/5
  • Creativity: 5/5
  • Characters: 5/5
  • Engrossing: 4/5
  • Writing: 5/5
  • Appeal to teens: 4/5
  • Appropriate length to tell the story: 5/5

  • Language: very mild; one a** and one bi***
  • Sexuality: mild-moderate; some kissing, one intense kiss that involves thigh-groping, a few round-about references to "having some fun" with pretty girls
  • Violence: mild-moderate; a man is magically cut in half, two bloody confrontations with the volcra (winged monsters)
  • Drugs/Alcohol: mild; adults drink "kvas" (a Russian beer)

Like this blog? Get updates in your inbox whenever I post new content! Subscribe by clicking the green envelope below:


  1. I cant wait to read this one. Love the review..

    Jenea @ Books Live Forever

  2. "The 'evil' characters seem to truly believe they are doing the right thing" - Characters are so much more complex and realistic when an author chooses to make their bad guys like this, so I'm glad to hear this. Glad that it has wonderful world building, too.

    Wonderful review! :)

  3. This was a fantastic book. I'm glad you liked it too. BTW, I totally agree with your recommendation. Because the set-up takes so long and the world-building is so strong, this is not a book I would recommend to reluctant readers. And it's definitely going on my best 0f 2102 list.

  4. I lent my ARC to a really good 8th grade boy reader in my school. He loved it, but I had to talk him through the first little bit of slow stuff. I told him, wait until they get attacked on the Shadow Fold. He kept reading and ended up loving it.

  5. I loved the combination of tension and humor in the story. I especially loved that the villain wasn't the obvious character with shifty eyes and rude character. As Alina says, "He sounded so sincere, so reasonable, less a creature of relentless ambition than a man who believed he was doing the right thing for his people. Despite all he'd done and all he intended, I did almost believe him. Almost." So did I, Alina. So did I.

  6. This just in today--Shadow and Bone is on the prestigious Lone Star Reading List for 2013-2014! Awesome!!!!! Here's the link to the list--


Let's start a conversation! All commenting on Mrs. ReaderPants is moderated and CAPTCHA-free! Please submit your comment only once--it will appear shortly.